What is an effective tax rate and how do I estimate it?

An effective tax rate is your total tax paid divided by your total income, expressed as a single percentage. You can estimate it by looking at last year’s tax return or using a good online tax calculator and then entering that percentage here.

Why doesn’t the calculator handle detailed tax brackets or filing status?

To stay fast and simple, this tool uses a single effective tax rate instead of modeling complex tax brackets, deductions, and credits. It’s meant for quick cash-flow comparisons, not precise tax planning.

How should I value benefits like health insurance from a second job?

Benefits are not modeled directly, but you can approximate them by adding the annual value of those benefits to the second income, or by mentally adjusting the net difference to account for them when you interpret the results.

Does this calculator tell us what we should do?

No. It highlights the financial side of the decision by showing net cash flow, but it does not include career growth, job satisfaction, family time, or long-term retirement effects. Use it as one input among many when deciding what is best for your household.

finance calculator

Two Income vs One Income

Compare net take-home for dual-income vs single-income households after taxes, work-related costs, and childcare.

Results

Net income (two earners): $81,400
Net income (one earner): $54,600
Net difference (two vs one): $26,800

How to use this calculator

Enter Income #1 and Income #2 as annual gross incomes before taxes.
Enter your total annual work-related costs that exist because both people are working (commute, parking, extra vehicle, meals out, professional wardrobe, etc.).
Enter annual childcare costs driven by having two working adults (daycare, preschool, before/after-school programs, sitters, or nannies).
Enter a combined effective tax rate that reflects your overall tax burden (federal, state, local, and payroll taxes) as a single percentage.
Review the net income with two earners after taxes, work costs, and childcare costs.
Review the net income with one earner after taxes, assuming the work-related and childcare costs you entered fall away.
Look at the net difference to see whether the second income adds enough cash flow to justify the time, stress, and opportunity cost.
Experiment with different combinations of income, costs, and tax rates to see how changes in your situation affect the gap between one and two incomes.

Inputs explained

Income #1: The annual gross income for the primary earner. In the one-income scenario, we assume this earner keeps working at this income level.
Income #2: The annual gross income for the second earner. In the one-income scenario, we assume this income drops to zero.
Work-related costs (commute, meals, etc.): Total annual work expenses that are only there because both adults are working: commuting (fuel, tolls, parking), a second car, professional clothing, dry cleaning, lunches out, and similar costs.
Childcare costs: Total annual childcare spending that is necessary because both adults work—daycare, preschool, before/after-school care, nannies, or sitters.
Combined effective tax rate (%): Your estimated overall tax rate on income once you blend federal, state, local, and payroll taxes. This is a single average rate used to approximate take-home pay in both scenarios, not a detailed tax calculation.

How it works

We start by adding Income #1 and Income #2 together to get your combined gross household income in the two-income scenario.

We apply your chosen combined effective tax rate to that total to estimate after-tax income for a two-income household.

From that two-income after-tax amount, we subtract the work-related costs you enter (commuting, meals out, professional clothing, etc.) and childcare costs that are only necessary because both adults are working.

The result is net income for the two-income scenario: the cash your household keeps after taxes and incremental work/childcare expenses.

For the one-income scenario, we assume Income #1 continues, Income #2 stops, and we apply the same effective tax rate to Income #1 alone to estimate after-tax pay.

We do not subtract work or childcare costs in the one-income scenario, treating them as expenses that largely disappear if one person steps out of the workforce.

Finally, we subtract the one-income net from the two-income net to show the difference—how much more (or less) cash flow the second job actually adds after all of those costs.

When to use it

Deciding whether one partner should pause or leave the workforce after having children and understanding the impact on net cash flow.
Comparing a full-time second job to a part-time or freelance alternative by entering different income and cost scenarios.
Evaluating the impact of rising childcare costs on whether it still makes sense to keep a second income.
Stress-testing your budget before making a big lifestyle change, such as staying home with kids or switching to a lower-paying but more flexible job.
Using alongside a broader family budget to see how much of the second income is truly available for savings, debt payoff, or lifestyle upgrades.

Tips & cautions

Use a realistic effective tax rate based on your actual prior-year return or a good online tax calculator, not just your top marginal bracket.
Include all incremental work-related costs, not just commuting—daycare surcharges, convenience meals, and professional clothing can materially reduce the value of a second income.
Run multiple scenarios: one with your current setup and others with alternative jobs, reduced hours, or different childcare arrangements.
Remember that benefits like health insurance, retirement matches, stock compensation, and paid time off from the second job are not modeled here but may be financially significant.
Consider both the short-term cash flow impact and the long-term career and earnings growth that may arise from staying in or stepping out of the workforce.
Uses a single effective tax rate and does not model progressive tax brackets, filing status, or detailed deductions and credits.
Assumes work-related and childcare costs drop to zero in the one-income scenario, which may not be fully true in every household.
Does not account for non-cash benefits such as health insurance, retirement plan matches, stock grants, or paid leave from either job.
Treats both incomes as stable and does not project raises, promotions, or long-term career effects of exiting the workforce.
Provides a snapshot of annual net cash flow only and should not be used by itself for long-term career, childcare, or retirement decisions.

Worked examples

Second income mostly eaten by childcare

Set Income #1 to $80,000 and Income #2 to $40,000.
Enter $12,000 of work-related costs (second car, commuting, lunches out) and $18,000 of annual childcare.
Use a 24% combined effective tax rate.
Compare the net income in the two-income scenario to the one-income scenario where only the $80,000 earner continues working.
Interpretation: if the net difference is small or negative, the second job may add little financial benefit after taxes and expenses.

High-paying second income that still wins after costs

Set Income #1 to $70,000 and Income #2 to $90,000.
Enter $15,000 of combined work-related costs and $20,000 of childcare expenses.
Use a 28% effective tax rate to reflect a higher-income household.
Review the net two-income versus one-income results and focus on the difference.
Interpretation: even after significant taxes and costs, a high second income may still add substantial net cash flow for savings or debt payoff.

Deep dive

Use this two income vs one income calculator to see whether a second job really pays off after taxes, commuting, and childcare costs.

Enter both incomes, work-related expenses, childcare, and an effective tax rate to compare net cash flow with two earners versus one earner.

Ideal for couples deciding if one partner should stay home with kids, reduce hours, or switch jobs while keeping an eye on the household bottom line.

FAQs

What is an effective tax rate and how do I estimate it?: An effective tax rate is your total tax paid divided by your total income, expressed as a single percentage. You can estimate it by looking at last year’s tax return or using a good online tax calculator and then entering that percentage here.
Why doesn’t the calculator handle detailed tax brackets or filing status?: To stay fast and simple, this tool uses a single effective tax rate instead of modeling complex tax brackets, deductions, and credits. It’s meant for quick cash-flow comparisons, not precise tax planning.
How should I value benefits like health insurance from a second job?: Benefits are not modeled directly, but you can approximate them by adding the annual value of those benefits to the second income, or by mentally adjusting the net difference to account for them when you interpret the results.
Does this calculator tell us what we should do?: No. It highlights the financial side of the decision by showing net cash flow, but it does not include career growth, job satisfaction, family time, or long-term retirement effects. Use it as one input among many when deciding what is best for your household.

Related calculators

finance

Discretionary Income Calculator

See how much discretionary income you have after paying yourself first and covering fixed and variable expenses each month.

finance

Paycheck Calculator

Estimate take-home pay by entering salary, pay frequency, pretax contributions, and tax rates.

finance

Income Numbers Converter

Turn an annual income (or any amount) into hourly, daily, weekly, biweekly, and monthly figures, optionally for a percentage of that amount.

This two income vs one income calculator is an educational tool designed to provide a simplified view of household cash flow. It does not account for detailed tax rules, benefits, or long-term career and retirement impacts and should not be treated as personalized financial advice. Consider speaking with a qualified financial planner or tax professional before making major work or family decisions.